Shaman and Dryad are special cases and represent group of few t1 units that are used throughout the whole game, but lets look at all t1 units played in PvP at higher ranks. Fire t1: Sunstriders, Scavenger, Thugs, Firesworn - only Firesworn is vary rarely used in t2 but u can definitely just use Gladiatrix as L counter so we can conclude that u have 3 or 4 dead slots in t2,t3 Nature t1: Swiftclaw, Shaman , Dryad, Windweavers, Spearman or Warebeasts, Amazon, Tree Spirit - you can use Shaman and Dryad and maybe Amazon in 1 of 20 games, Tree Spirit i wont count because i never seen high ranked root PvP player, maybe some top naure players used it in a few games but that was not their main deck. So if u play typical nature t1 u have at least 3 dead slots in t2, t3 Shadow t1: Nox Trooper, Forsaken, Skeleton Warriors, Wrathblades, Dreadcharger, Nightgurad - Only Nightgurad used in t2 so depending on your t1 choice u have atleast 3 or 4 deadslots in t1,t2 Frost t1: Ice Guradian, Master Archers, Frost Mage, Frost Sorceress, Imperials, Lightblade - Frost Mage can be used in t2, Frost Sorceress can have some use in t2, and i would say only Lightblade is really worth to use in t2, so again we have 3 or more dead slots in t2,t3 The Lord of the Rings t1: Trow one "Heir of Isildur" in 10 000 Uruk-Hai and break the siege of Helm's Deep Now why Tree Spirit is not used by more high ranked players, simply because all higher ranked players are old players and already have their main decks with which they got to the top, and Amii Edition which brought us our beloved Tree Spirit was released late to a very small, old and dying player base, and that is why it only led to the rise in ranks of only one top 50 player who was frustrated with his ranked position and was not able to go to even in top 40 with any conventional deck. True high ranked players get advantage in t1 and u cannot do that with Tree Spirit, you skip t1 with Tree Spirit and win because of big ass t3. I do not mean to offend you and idk what you rank was, but your reasoning is really bad, they do not just spam trees, they take a well and if u try to attack they spam trees on that well and they are able to def with 100 less power, if i take a well too when he takes a well we are on equal power but t1 is skipped and i have at least 3 dead slots in my deck while he has only 1 dead slot, and this is exactly what im talking about. You use Tree Spirit in t2 when u have left overs on field from t1. T1 is not and should never be skippable and is where 90% of high ranked games are determined. U should never be able to just take a well and wait to t2, map control and a big advantage should be a result from a t1 fight that all players of equal rank in PvP should be forced to do. Vs any other top 20 player i would have to have a big t1 fight which would at least determine who has map control. If i just took a well on smaler to mid sized map vs any other top 20 player they would crush me, and thats how it should be when u just spend 100 power this early with no advantage . The fact remains u are the only top 20 player with no t1, and super big t3 and all u do is drag the game to t3 and win with 5 card t3, when all other top players can only have 2-3 cards in t3. It is really hard to beat a nature/frost in t2 with 0 advantage from t1, since it is a most defensive deck and its always 10 times easyer to def then to attack, and to do so u would need to be on much higher level skill wise. I am not attacking you, i am attacking PvP play style you promote which is the subject of this tread. Tree Spirit forces your opponent to be completely passive even when you give him 100 power advantage so early in the game, and it works vs all decks, this is just so broken. This alone is more then enough reason to rework this card plus the 5 card t3 it allows.